Skip to content
Discover the vibrant culture, hidden gems, and local insigh…

A United Ireland Plebiscite Cannot Turn Into 'Another Brexit', Commentators Warn

A decade after the UK stumbled into a hasty public vote that divided the nation and caused disorder, a warning comes from across the Irish Sea: it may occur once more.

Policymakers and electorate drifted into Brexit and the same may happen with a referendum on a unified Ireland, initiating disturbances for which no one is equipped.

That is the message from two respected journalists from each side of the Irish border who have collaborated to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to form a new state with the Republic of Ireland.

Political Structures Ill-Equipped

Fintan O’Toole and Sam McBride, have determined that the administrative systems in Ireland and Britain are extremely unprepared for a potentially tense and transformative referendum.

"The crucial insight of Brexit has gone unabsorbed, which is that stuff can emerge unexpectedly and can gain traction rapidly," O’Toole said. "In my opinion that the institutional structure of our region remains extremely volatile."

New Title Intends to Stir Debate

The duo have examined the political, financial and cultural reasons for any constitutional change in a publication, The Case For and Against Unification, issued by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.

They aim to encourage dialogue on the matter with a series of public talks that will lead them to Westminster soon.

"What haunts everybody, or ought to concern all involved, is the Brexit vote of 2016," stated O’Toole.

"We should prevent a referendum on a thumbs up-thumbs down, ambiguous question whose consequences have not been spelled out because then you end up with an extraordinarily split population where those defeated are not reconciled to losing and the victorious side don't know precisely what it is that they have gained."

Constitutional Provision

Under the Belfast Agreement, the Northern Ireland government minister should call a public vote on Irish unification if it appears likely that a most voters would support.

Nationalist parties and other pro-unification groups claim such a time is approaching, and a organisation named Ireland’s Future has rallied support, but both governments and pro-UK factions play down the likelihood, making it uncertain whether or when there might be a referendum.

Insufficient Informed Dialogue

Political rhetoric supporting and opposing unification has obscured the shortage of informed dialogue, said McBride.

"Many are supportive or opposed the concept but the detailed consideration which could extend past that to make it possible has largely not occurred. A lot has gone on in scholarly circles but hardly any government figures or campaigners want to engage even with the fundamentals. As an example, what type of nation might be preferred? Centralised? Federal?"

Publication's Method

In the book, no writer supports unification or the existing arrangement. They writes two articles that aim for objectivity in laying out the case for a united Ireland and the rationale against, marshalling economic and social statistics, historical precedents and governmental frameworks.

Arguments range over flags and symbols, levies, healthcare systems, pensions, sovereign debt obligations and the threat of unionist unrest. The objective is to enlighten and stimulate discussion.

"Considerable attention exists in the subject but there is still lacking a dialogue," said O’Toole. "Dialogue suggests an recognition of the notion that there could be reasonable perspectives on either side."

Parallel Votes

A referendum in Northern Ireland would simultaneously prompt one in the Republic of Ireland, where the electorate report they prefer unification but refuse paying higher taxes or introducing a alternative symbol to recognise unionists' British culture.

"The Irish government must establish what the plan from Irish nationalism is aside from just stating: 'We seek a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," remarked O’Toole.

Likelihood of Referendum

McBride thinks a referendum in his generation is likely and that it might occur suddenly. "It is possible just a mad or a ill-advised or a negligent secretary of state who declares: 'Let's just do this and resolve it.'"

Each of the pro-unification advocates and pro-UK supporters have plausible, justified points, he stated. "Somebody will succeed in this matter and somebody will eventually lose but each side has has valuable insights to learn from the other's positions."

Call for Wider Dialogue

Westminster needed to participate in the discussion, said the analyst. "This concerns Britain. It is a UK matter just as much as it is an Irish issue."

Written by

Scott Thomas

A seasoned traveler and writer passionate about uncovering the soul of Dutch cities.

Cool Journal Den Haag

Type to search articles.